sir_guinglain

My review of The Timeless Children, like that of Ascension of the Cybermen, appears at Space-Time Telegraph, the blog which is the successor of its writer-editor John Connors's fanzines, which included Top, Faze and This Way Up. I wrote it having only seen the story once and much of my initial enthusiasm was qualified by other people's reservations. Having rewatched some of the episode since, I was reminded of the focused performances throughout and minimizing of languor. Jodie Whittaker's portrayal of the Doctor's fury and disgust at the Master was electrical, combined with eye-rolling expressions of frustration at just how tedious her old friend can be.

I wrote in the review that there had been no indication in Ascension of the Cybermen that the Doctor was periodically experiencing chapters in the saga of Brendan the Irish policeman - 'Gallykissangel', as I've called it, the term having been suggested by Paul Dumont. Ian Bayley has pointed out that there are odd lines of dialogue in Ascension which might suggest that the Doctor is being surprised by new Brendan scenes, but if so I still find them very understated.

As for the review itself:

So it was about authorship after all. Ascension of the Cybermen turns out to have been undermined throughout by a streaming hacker who couldn’t resist introducing it himself at the end and boasting of his reinterpretation of the ensuing acts, of which the Doctor was both audience and unwitting star. The Timeless Children was visually engaging television and I was surprised by some of the resolution it presented, if only because I was expecting something more complicated. Performances were very strong, and as with Ascension of the Cybermen, I felt an energy in the production which I’ve rarely experienced in the Chibnall era. There were a few moments when it seemed The Timeless Children did not marry so well with Ascension of the Cybermen, however, and in hindsight the episode left lingering doubts about the wisdom of the decisions therein.

Read more...

• ‘Perhaps I’ve thought everything I’ll ever think’ – Ian Bayley discusses the Society’s predictions for Series 11


• The Victoria Line – Society President Victoria Walker reviews each episode of Series 11


• ‘If I was still a bloke, I could just get on with the job and not have to waste time defending myself’ – Georgia Harper discusses the response to the Thirteenth Doctor’s debut


• Team, gang, fam? –  Francis Stojsavljevic summarises the collective views of the Society on the episodes, characters and features of Series 11


• ‘I’ve lost track of what’s actually happening’ – Georgia Harper relays the reactions of Time and Relative Dimensions in Shitposting


• Say you want a Resolution – Matthew Kilburn reviews the New Year’s Special

• Haiku for The Woman Who Fell To Earth by William Shaw


• Haiku for The Witchfinders by William Shaw


• Haiku for Resolution by William Shaw

• Timewyrm Tales – James Ashworth reviews the first four novels of the Virgin New Adventures


• Bookwyrm Reviewed – Stephen Brennan reviews Bookwyrm, the new novel exploring the New Adventures in their entirety, from Robert Smith? and society alumnus Anthony Wilson


• You all right, Hun? – Georgia Harper reviews the new Thirteenth Doctor novel, Combat Magicks

• Wise Men Say – Andrew O’Day discusses the allegories of Kinda andSnakedance


• As Time Goes By – Oli Jones defends The Time of the Doctor


• Top or Flop: The Capaldi Conundrum –  James Ashworth and Ian Bayley debate the relative merits of the Capaldi-era titles


• Hail to the Chief – Rory Salt shines light on the work of Big Chief Studios


• Hmm? – Ian Bayley discusses David Bradley’s work on Doctor Who, after his visit to the Oxford Union


• Equilibrium by Philip Holdridge, featuring the new TARDIS crew on a mission to another universe